| Date | Opponent | Time | Result | ||
| *NCAA DIII 2009 Men's Bracket* | |||||
| November | |||||
| Tue | 18 | at Ramapo | Final | 70-80 Loss | Box Score Recap |
| Fri | 21 | at Montclair State (@ Albright) | Final | 72-60 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 22 | at Albright | Final | 77-62 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Tue | 25 | at Baruch | Final | 79-72 Win | Box Score Recap |
| December | |||||
| Tue | 2 | at Polytechnic* | Final | 86-64 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 6 | at Maritime* | Final | 73-84 Loss | Box Score Recap |
| Mon | 8 | at Staten Island | Final | 81-58 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Wed | 10 | Bard* | Final | 80-52 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Tue | 16 | New Jersey City | Final | 104-60 Win | Box Score Recap |
| January | |||||
| Tue | 6 | Old Westbury* | Final | 99-81 Win | Box Score Recap Audio |
| Thu | 8 | at St. Joseph's* | Final | 84-67 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 10 | at Mount Saint Mary* | Final | 95-47 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 17 | Mount Saint Vincent* | Final | 113-71 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Tue | 20 | at Yeshiva* | Final | 78-63 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Thu | 22 | at Purchase* | Final | 91-80 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 24 | at Old Westbury* | Final | 92-83 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Tue | 27 | Polytechnic* | Final | 110-71 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 31 | Maritime* | Final | 91-57 Win | Box Score Recap |
| February | |||||
| Mon | 2 | NYCCT | Final | 77-62 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Wed | 4 | at Bard* | Final | 88-75 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 7 | Mount Saint Mary* | Final | 88-60 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Thu | 12 | St. Joseph's* | Final | 66-61 Win | Box Score Recap Audio |
| Sat | 14 | Yeshiva* | Final | 84-59 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Wed | 18 | Purchase* | Final | 87-81 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 21 | at Mount Saint Vincent* | Final | 107-81 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Tue | 24 | at Skyline Quarterfinals - BYE | -- | ||
| Thu | 26 | Skyline Semifinals - #4 Old Westbury | Final | 73-59 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 28 | Skyline Championship - #2 St. Joe's | Final | 68-69 Loss | Box Score Recap Audio |
| March | |||||
| Fri | 6 | at UNE - NCAA First Round (@ Rhode Island College) | Final | 90-73 Win | Box Score Recap Video |
| Sat | 7 | at MIT - NCAA Second Round (@ Rhode Island College) | Final | 67-61 Win | Box Score Recap Video |
| Fri | 13 | at Bridgewater St. - NCAA Sweet 16 (@ Richard Stockton) | Final | 84-64 Win | Box Score Recap Video |
| Sat | 14 | at Richard Stockton - NCAA Elite 8 (@ Richard Stockton) | Final | 60-103 Loss | Box Score Recap Video |
"*" Indicates Skyline Conference Games
Home Games in BOLD