| Date | Opponent | Time | Result | ||
| March | |||||
| Tue | 10 | at Spring Trip: Disney Wide World of Sports (March 10-15) | ---- | ||
| Tue | 10 | at Post Univ. (Conn.) | Final | 6-2 Win | Box Score |
| Tue | 10 | at Newbury (Mass.) | Final | 14-0 Win | Box Score |
| Wed | 11 | at Thomas College (Maine) | Final | 4-0 Win | Box Score |
| Wed | 11 | at Bridgewater State (Mass.) | Final (8) | 3-2 Win | Box Score |
| Wed | 11 | at Bridgewater State (Mass.) | Final | 2-4 Loss | Box Score |
| Thu | 12 | at Salve Regina (R.I.) | Final | 4-1 Win | Box Score |
| Thu | 12 | at Salve Regina (R.I.) | Final | 6-4 Win | Box Score |
| Fri | 13 | at Penn State Hazleton | Final | 11-4 Win | Box Score |
| Fri | 13 | at Penn State Hazleton | Final | 10-2 Win | Box Score |
| Fri | 13 | at Rutgers-Camden | Final | 1-19 Loss | Box Score |
| Sat | 14 | at Rutgers-Camden | Final (8) | 2-1 Win | Box Score |
| Sat | 14 | at St. Joseph's (Conn.) | Final | 2-1 Win | Box Score |
| Wed | 18 | at Briarcliffe - Game 1 | Final | 12-4 Win | Box Score |
| Wed | 18 | at Briarcliffe - Game 2 | Final | 10-1 Win | Box Score |
| Sat | 21 | at Mount Saint Mary* - Game 1 | Final | 10-0 Win | Box Score |
| Sat | 21 | at Mount Saint Mary* - Game 2 | Final | 10-0 Win | Box Score |
| Sun | 22 | Manhattanville - Game 1 | Final | 8-0 Win | Box Score |
| Sun | 22 | Manhattanville - Game 2 | Final | 3-0 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Wed | 25 | Merchant Marine - Game 1 | Final | 0-6 Loss | Box Score |
| Wed | 25 | Merchant Marine - Game 2 | Final | 9-6 Win | Box Score |
| Tue | 31 | Drew University - Game 1 | Final | 2-1 Win | Box Score |
| Tue | 31 | Drew University - Game 2 | Final | 5-1 Win | Box Score Recap |
| April | |||||
| Sun | 5 | at Mount Saint Vincent* - Game 1 | Final | 12-0 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sun | 5 | at Mount Saint Vincent* - Game 2 | Final | 19-0 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Mon | 13 | at Polytechnic* - Game 1 | Final | 10-2 Win | Box Score |
| Mon | 13 | at Polytechnic* - Game 2 | Final | 11-1 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Wed | 15 | Old Westbury* Game - 1 | Final | 3-1 Win | Box Score |
| Wed | 15 | Old Westbury* Game - 2 | Final | 6-0 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 18 | Sage* - Game 1 | Final | 4-0 Win | Box Score |
| Sat | 18 | Sage* - Game 2 | Final | 2-3 Loss | Box Score |
| Sun | 19 | at Purchase* - Game 1 | Final | 11-2 Win | Box Score |
| Sun | 19 | at Purchase* - Game 2 | Final | 13-2 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Thu | 23 | at Ramapo (DH) | Cancelled | ||
| Sat | 25 | St. Joseph's* - Game 1 | Final | 11-3 Win | Box Score |
| Sat | 25 | St. Joseph's* - Game 2 | Final | 17-0 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Wed | 29 |
#4 Mount Saint Mary - Skyline Tournament First Round |
Final | 5-3 Win | Box Score Recap |
| May | |||||
| Sat | 2 |
#2 Old Westbury - Skyline Tournament Second Round |
Final | 5-0 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sun | 3 | at #2 Old Westbury - Skyline Championship | Cancelled | Recap | |
| Wed | 6 | *NCAA DIII 2009 Softball Regional Bracket* | |||
| Thu | 7 |
at
#3 Rowan - NCAA Regionals (@ Ramapo College) |
Final | 1-7 Loss | Box Score Recap |
| Fri | 8 |
at
#7 Muhlenberg - NCAA Regionals (@ Ramapo College) |
Final | 4-1 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 9 |
at
#4 Moravian - NCAA Regionals (@ Ramapo) |
Final (8) | 3-1 Win | Box Score Recap |
| Sat | 9 |
at
Rowan - NCAA Regional (@ Ramapo) |
Final | 0-3 Loss | Box Score |
"*" Indicates Skyline Conference Games
Home Games in BOLD